
How to Audit Performance Max Campaigns: 7 Checks
Performance Max shows less by design. Audit it with 7 checks, starting with the branded search overlap Optmyzr found in 91.45% of 503 Google Ads accounts.
By Abhilash LR
Auditing a Performance Max campaign is harder than auditing Search for a structural reason. PMax deliberately shows you less: no keyword-level reporting, limited placement visibility, and asset-group performance that's directional rather than precise. The audit has to work around that opacity instead of pretending it isn't there.
The first thing to look at is branded search overlap. An Optmyzr study of 503 accounts found keyword overlap between Search and PMax in 91.45% of them. This guide walks through seven checks, from the highest-value one down to routine hygiene. If you'd rather hand the whole job to someone else, Loupe is a fixed-price option. For a broader view of warning signs, see our guide to PPC audit red flags.
Key Takeaways
- Start with branded search overlap. An Optmyzr study of 503 accounts (February 2025) found 91.45% had keyword overlap between Search and PMax, affecting 56% of Search campaigns.
- Google's documentation says an exact-match Search keyword should win the auction over PMax for that query. That only holds if your Search campaign is eligible to serve.
- Search beat PMax more often than PMax beat Search. Search beat PMax on conversion rate more often than the reverse (18.91% vs 6.17%), but in most overlapping cases (74.92%) there was no significant difference.
- Asset groups and search term insights deserve the most time, since they're the closest thing to keyword-level visibility PMax offers.
Why Is Performance Max Hard to Audit?
Performance Max is hard to audit because it hides detail that Search campaigns expose. There's no keyword-level reporting, placement visibility is limited, and asset-group performance is directional rather than precise. An auditor can't read a keyword list and spot waste. The work shifts to eligibility, inputs and the few reports PMax does provide.
That changes what an audit looks like. In a Search account, you'd scan keywords, match types and search terms line by line. Here, you check the conditions around the campaign: which other campaigns can serve, what assets feed it, and what the insights report reveals.
Think of it as auditing the inputs and the neighbours. You can't open the box, so you inspect everything that goes into it and everything sitting next to it. If you haven't used the reporting views much, our walkthrough on how to read Ads Manager is a useful companion.
Check 1: Is Branded Search Overlap Costing You?
Overlap between Search and PMax is common. Optmyzr's February 2025 study of 503 accounts found keyword overlap in 91.45% of them. It affected 56.29% of Search campaigns and 27.86% of ad groups. Check it first, because it's high-value and easy to miss.
Google's documentation states plainly: "A Search campaign with a keyword that exactly matches or is spell-corrected to a person's query will be preferred over Performance Max." In theory, an exact-match branded keyword should never lose to PMax for that exact query.
One plausible explanation (our inference, not stated in the study): a Search campaign becomes ineligible to serve, through a budget limit, a targeting mismatch or a paused status, just as PMax is ready to fill the gap.
What to look at:
- Branded Search budget. Open the branded campaign and check whether it's labelled budget-limited. Good: fully funded, never capped. Bad: capped early in the day.
- Eligibility. Check whether the campaign is enabled, targeted to the same locations and not paused by a schedule or a status issue.
- PMax search term insights. Look for your brand terms. Meaningful volume there suggests PMax is winning auctions your exact-match keyword should have won.
- Recent changes. Check whether any budget or bidding-strategy change hit the Search campaign recently.
Check 2: Asset Group Focus and Quality
Each asset group needs enough distinct headlines, descriptions and images for Google's system to test combinations meaningfully. A single asset group covering unrelated product categories dilutes the signal Google needs to learn what works for each one. Audit the groups for focus first, then for asset quality.
What to look at:
- Theme per group. Good: one group per coherent product line or offer. Bad: one group covering unrelated categories.
- Asset variety. Check whether headlines, descriptions and images are genuinely different, not rewordings of each other.
- Performance labels. Read the Low, Good and Best labels, then replace or improve any asset labelled Low.
- Message match. Check whether the assets promise what the landing page delivers.
Treat the labels as directional. They tell you where to look, not what to conclude.
Check 3: What Do Search Term Insights Reveal?
Search term insights are PMax's closest substitute for a Search Terms Report. They're also where Check 1's brand-overlap investigation actually gets done. Review them for query categories that have no business being funded by this campaign, the same way you'd review a Search campaign's search terms.
PMax doesn't offer keyword-level negatives. That doesn't mean irrelevant traffic isn't happening. It means catching it takes an extra step: account-level negative keyword lists, which do apply to PMax.
What to look at:
- Brand terms. Note how much volume appears and compare it with your branded Search campaign.
- Irrelevant categories. Look for themes that don't match what you sell, such as job seekers or free-resource queries.
- Negative lists. Check whether an account-level list exists and whether it's applied.
- Lead quality. If you run lead generation, compare these themes against complaints about junk enquiries. Our post on low-quality leads in Google Ads covers that side.
Check 4: Product Feed Health
This check applies only if the campaign includes a product feed. Feed errors can silently suppress impressions on affected products, with no obvious error in the campaign's headline metrics. Merchant Center diagnostics is where the evidence lives, so start there.
What to look at:
- Disapproved products. Check how many are disapproved and why.
- GTINs. Check whether identifiers are missing on products that should have them.
- Price accuracy. Compare feed prices against your live site.
- Availability accuracy. Compare stock status in the feed with what shoppers see on the site.
A healthy feed shows few disapprovals and prices that match the site. A neglected one shows growing diagnostics warnings nobody has opened.
Check 5: Conversion Goals and Tracking
PMax optimises toward the conversions you give it, so the conversion setup deserves its own check. If tracking is wrong, every other check rests on bad data. Confirm the right actions are counted before judging performance, budgets or assets.
Check whether:
- Conversion actions exist for the outcomes you actually care about.
- Primary and secondary goals are set deliberately, not by default.
- Tracking fires correctly on the thank-you page or event.
- Conversion values match real revenue or lead value, if you use value-based bidding.
If any of that is shaky, fix it first. Our guide to setting up conversion tracking covers the basics, and the post on attribution and measurement explains why numbers differ between platforms.
Check 6: URL Expansion and Brand Exclusions
These settings control where traffic lands and which queries the campaign can chase. Review them on purpose rather than leaving them as they were at launch. This check needs no theory about how Google behaves. It only needs you to confirm each setting matches your intent.
Check whether:
- Final URL expansion is on or off, and whether that choice fits your site.
- Any pages that shouldn't receive paid traffic are excluded.
- Brand exclusions are configured, and whether they match your plan for branded Search.
- Your landing pages still exist and still match the offer.
If you've set brand exclusions, compare them against Check 1. The two should tell a consistent story about who owns branded queries.
Check 7: Do Audience Signals, Targets and New-Customer Settings Fit?
The last check ties settings back to business reality. Audience signals, bid targets and the new-customer setting are easy to set once and forget. Revisit them against current goals, margins and customer data.
Check whether:
- Audience signals still reflect your best customers and current lists.
- Your target (target ROAS or target CPA) still matches your unit economics, including current margins and average order value.
- The new-customer setting matches whether you want growth or repeat sales.
- Budget changes have been gradual. Sudden jumps can hurt results, as we explain in why scaling budget breaks ROAS.
A target set two quarters ago may no longer reflect what a customer is worth.
Audit Summary Table
| Check | What it catches | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| Branded search overlap | PMax winning auctions Search should win by default | Search term insights + brand campaign eligibility |
| Asset group quality | Diluted learning signal across unrelated products | Asset performance labels |
| Search term insights | Irrelevant query categories funded with no visibility | PMax's own insights report |
| Feed quality (if applicable) | Suppressed impressions from feed errors | Merchant Center diagnostics |
| Conversion goals and tracking | Optimising toward wrong or missing conversions | Conversion settings |
| URL expansion and brand exclusions | Settings that no longer match intent | Campaign settings |
| Audiences, targets, new-customer | Targets that ignore current economics | Campaign and asset group settings |
For a sense of how often to repeat all this, read how often to audit Google Ads. If you want to compare tools first, there's a roundup of free Google Ads audit tools.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Performance Max really steal branded search traffic?
The mechanism is more specific than stealing. Google's own rule says an exact-match Search keyword should win over PMax for that query. A large study found this doesn't consistently play out, and our inference is that the Search campaign becomes ineligible at the moment PMax fills in. Make sure your branded Search campaign is never the constrained one.
Can I get keyword-level reporting inside Performance Max?
Not directly. Search campaigns report by keyword, but PMax doesn't. Search term insights and asset-group performance labels are the closest substitutes. Checks 2 and 3 above are built around using them as well as they can be used.
Should I turn off Performance Max because of the overlap risk?
The study doesn't make that case. Search beat PMax on conversion rate more often than the reverse (18.91% vs 6.17%), but in most overlapping cases (74.92%) there was no significant difference. Protect your branded terms through the eligibility check instead of abandoning PMax entirely.
How often should I check search term insights?
A monthly check is a practical cadence. Add one right after any budget or bidding-strategy change to a co-existing Search campaign, because that kind of change can make the Search campaign temporarily ineligible. Our post on how often to audit Google Ads covers cadence more broadly.
What if I find brand-term overlap and can't tell why?
Check budget-limited status on the Search campaign first. It's the first thing to rule out. If the Search campaign is fully funded and eligible and the overlap persists, that's an unusual finding worth a closer, second-opinion look.
Should I hire someone to audit this for me?
It depends on your time and confidence with the reports. Branded-search overlap is easy to miss because nothing about it looks like an error in day-to-day reporting. If you do hire, read questions to ask before hiring an ad auditor first.
Get Your Account Audited
Loupe by COACT is a one-time Meta + Google Ads audit. It includes a 133-point review, a recorded walkthrough and prioritised fixes. There's no retainer, and pricing is fixed at US$199, US$299 or US$399. If you'd rather talk through your account first, contact COACT and we'll point you the right way.
Abhilash LR is the founder of COACT, a growth-focused agency operating across India, Southeast Asia and Singapore. He has spent a decade working with startups and scaleups, where he kept seeing the same problems: businesses leaving growth on the table because of the wrong partners, systems, strategy and incomplete data loops. COACT is built on the principles he works by: performance-driven, founder-obsessed, and focused on what actually moves the needle. COACT also sells Loupe, a fixed-price ad account audit. Questions or corrections: contact us. Learn more about COACT.
Published at www.coact.biz2026-09-30 · Abhilash LRWant results like these for your brand?
COACT runs performance-based growth across SEA & India. Start with a free 15-day pilot.
Book a strategy callKeep reading
Audit Findings: What to Do With Them, Step by Step
Turn audit findings into fixes in five steps, tracking first. Get an impact and effort table and learn how to judge a fix after Google's 7-day learning window.
Ad Account Audit: Do It In-House or Hire Someone?
Audit your ad account yourself or hire out? Use a 3-question test and a hybrid workflow, or a US$199 fixed-fee audit as a starting point if you need help.